BayRobin vs Smith.ai for Auto Repair Shops (2026)
Smith.ai sells AI and human receptionists billed per call, with a page for repair shops. BayRobin is an AI receptionist built for independent shops that books the appointment and runs the job. Here's the comparison.
Smith.ai is an answering service with AI-first and human-first plans. It says it has 10 years in business, 20 million calls and more than 5,000 businesses as customers. Its page for car dealers and repair shops describes AI handling routine bookings like oil changes and tire rotations, with North America-based human receptionists for complex service and warranty calls.
More on this topic: Shop software pricing and alternatives, every guide in one place.
BayRobin is an AI receptionist built for independent auto repair shops, inside a small shop system. It gets the year, make, model, mileage and concern, books the appointment as a job with the vehicle on it, and then carries the job through reminders, inspection, an estimate approved by text, the invoice and a review request. This post is for shop owners choosing between an answering service and an AI front office.
The short answer
Choose Smith.ai if you want trained people available on your calls, Spanish on a dedicated line, or a free AI plan for a handful of calls, and you're fine paying per call. Choose BayRobin if you want AI to answer and book every call at a flat monthly price, with missed-call text-back, reminders, inspections, estimates and invoices on the same job.
Key takeaways
- Smith.ai's AI receptionist is free for 25 calls a month, then from $150 a month for 75 calls on Pro, with extra calls billed per call.
- Its human receptionists start at $300 a month for 30 calls ($11.50 per extra call), with per-call add-ons: $1.50 to book an appointment, $1.00 for a dedicated Spanish line, $0.25 for recording and transcription.
- Smith.ai's repair-shop page names integrations like HubSpot, Calendly, Salesforce and ServiceTitan, but no auto repair shop software.
- BayRobin is AI only, English only, and transfers just urgent calls to your on-call person.
- BayRobin is a front office more than a full shop management system: the AI receptionist, missed-call text-back, online booking and reminders come with inspections, repair orders, invoices and a dispatch board on every plan, and AI call time is paid from the plan's monthly credits.
Disclosure: we make BayRobin, so weigh our view accordingly. Everything we say about Smith.ai comes from its own public pages or published reviews, checked in October 2026 and linked at the end. BayRobin is new and does less than Smith.ai in several areas; we list them.
BayRobin vs Smith.ai at a glance
| BayRobin | Smith.ai | |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers | AI, always | AI first, or human receptionists, by plan |
| Built for | Independent auto repair shops | Many industries, with a dealers and repair shops page |
| Where bookings go | BayRobin's own calendar and dispatch board, as a job with the vehicle | Your calendar or CRM through its integrations |
| Pricing | Flat monthly plans with credits for AI call time | Per call, by plan |
Pricing compared
Smith.ai publishes its prices. The AI plans are month to month with 30 days' notice to cancel; the human plans are month to month with 10% off for a 12-month commitment and a 30-day money-back guarantee capped at $1,000.
| BayRobin plan | Price |
|---|---|
| Starter | $149/month: 3 users, 2,000 credits a month (about 150 AI call minutes), every feature |
| Pro | $249/month: 8 users, 5,000 credits a month (about 400 AI call minutes), every feature |
| Shop | $399/month: 20 users, 12,000 credits a month (about 1,000 AI call minutes), every feature plus payroll |
Every plan has every feature, including inspections, repair orders, invoices and the dispatch board; only payroll is Shop-only. Plans are month to month with no contract or setup fee, and a plan's price doesn't go up while you stay on it. Yearly billing is 10× the monthly price (two months free). Credits also pay for the phone number, call minutes and call summaries, so the AI-minute figures are approximate. The launch offer is free until your first 10 booked jobs, with no card up front: jobs booked by the AI receptionist or your online booking page count.
| Smith.ai plan | Price |
|---|---|
| AI: Free | $0 for 25 calls a month, then $3.00 per call |
| AI: Pro | $150/month for 75 calls ($2.00 a call); higher tiers for 150 or 300 calls |
| AI: Enterprise | $500/month for 300 calls and up |
| Human: Starter / Basic / Pro | $300 for 30 calls / $810 for 90 / $2,100 for 300 a month; $11.50 / $10.50 / $8.50 per extra call |
| Human-plan add-ons, per call | Booking $1.50; dedicated Spanish line $1.00; recording and transcription $0.25 |
Take a shop that gets 100 calls a month it can't pick up. On Smith.ai's AI Pro plan, the 75-call tier is $150 plus 25 extra calls at $2.50, about $213; the 150-call tier costs more. Answered by humans, the Basic plan is $810 for 90 calls plus overage, and $1.50 more for each call it books. BayRobin Starter is $149 a month with about 150 AI call minutes; at a minute and a half per call that's roughly 100 calls, with text-back, booking, reminders, inspections and estimates included. If your calls run long, check what a busy month would use on Pro ($249, about 400 minutes).
Feature by feature: BayRobin vs Smith.ai
| BayRobin | Smith.ai | |
|---|---|---|
| Answering | AI receptionist answers 24/7 with your shop's name, asks what's wrong or what service they want, the year, make and model, rough mileage, whether they'll wait or drop off, and their name, then books an open time | AI handles routine calls like oil changes and tire rotations; humans take complex service and warranty calls |
| Vehicle details | Year, make, model and mileage on the job; vehicles on each customer, matched by VIN, then plate, then year, make and model; a VIN fills in year, make, model, trim and engine from NHTSA's free decoder; mileage on each job | Collects make, model, year, service needs and timeline |
| Booking | Offers real open times from your team's hours and bookings, shared out round robin, and books the appointment as a job with the vehicle on it | AI books straightforward appointments; humans book multi-service ones (booking is $1.50 a call on human plans) |
| Transfers | Urgent calls (won't start, brakes failing, overheating, unsafe to drive) get the earliest open time or a transfer to that day's on-call person, your choice; it suggests they don't drive it | Transfers to your service or sales team by your rules; urgent repairs go to service advisors |
| Languages | English only | Dedicated Spanish line on human plans ($1.00 a call) |
| Records | Call recording, transcript and summary on each job (recording can be turned off) | Recording and transcription ($0.25 a call on human plans) |
| Missed-call text-back | Missed-call text-back within a minute, on by default, message editable; replies land in your shared inbox; STOP honored | Not described |
| After the call | Reminders, inspection, estimate, invoice, pickup text and review request on the same job | Records logged in your systems through integrations |
What comes with BayRobin
Many independent shops pay for shop management software, a phone or answering add-on, a texting tool and a review tool, then copy the same customer between them. BayRobin puts the parts that win the job and bring the customer back in one place, starting at $149/month. If you're weighing Smith.ai, check which of these you'd pay extra for there.
| Included | What it does |
|---|---|
| AI receptionist | AI receptionist answers 24/7 with your shop's name, asks what's wrong or what service they want, the year, make and model, rough mileage, whether they'll wait or drop off, and their name, then books an open time |
| Urgent calls | Urgent calls (won't start, brakes failing, overheating, unsafe to drive) get the earliest open time or a transfer to that day's on-call person, your choice; it suggests they don't drive it |
| Missed-call text-back | Missed-call text-back within a minute, on by default, message editable; replies land in your shared inbox; STOP honored |
| Online booking and reminders | Online booking page (a link) that offers real open times, asks for texting consent and turns each booking into a scheduled job. Reminder text about a day before each appointment booked ahead; the customer replies C to confirm or R to reschedule |
| Vehicles and recalls | Vehicles on each customer, matched by VIN, then plate, then year, make and model; a VIN fills in year, make, model, trim and engine from NHTSA's free decoder; mileage on each job. Open NHTSA safety recalls for the vehicle's year, make and model on the repair order and inspection, marked "may apply" with a link to the VIN check |
| Inspections and estimates | Digital inspections on the technician's phone browser: each item green, yellow or red with notes and photos, and recommended work from the findings. Repair orders of labor (hours at your labor rate), parts and fees, built from canned jobs; the customer approves or declines each service on one link, and phone approvals are recorded with your name |
| Invoices and pickup | Approved work becomes the invoice, sent by text with a pay link; card payments through your own Stripe account, or PayPal. Ready for pickup: one button texts the customer their vehicle is ready, with the total and a pay-by-card link |
| Bringing customers back | Service-due texts by miles or months (mileage estimated from the vehicle's own readings), and texts about declined work 14 and 90 days later. One Google review request by text once an invoice is paid in full |
| Dispatch | Dispatch board on every plan: day and week views with one row per technician, drag to reassign or move, clash check, one-click text of the new time |
What BayRobin doesn't do
| Labor guide and repair data | No labor guide or repair data (no MOTOR, ALLDATA or ProDemand); you set your own labor hours and prices |
| Parts | No parts ordering, parts catalogs or inventory |
| Mobile app | No native app: technicians use My day in their phone's browser |
| Accounting | No QuickBooks or Xero sync |
| Financing | No consumer financing |
| Other shop software | No live connection to other shop software; forward calls to it and add bookings there yourself |
| Languages | The receptionist speaks English only |
Where Smith.ai is the better choice
Real people when you want them
Smith.ai's human receptionists can take warranty questions, multi-service bookings and payment conversations. BayRobin is AI only and takes a message when it can't help.
Spanish
A dedicated Spanish line is available on human plans. BayRobin's receptionist speaks English only.
A free start
The free AI plan covers 25 calls a month, which may be enough for a shop that misses only a few.
Track record
Ten years and 20 million calls, by Smith.ai's own count.
Where BayRobin is the better choice
Built for repair calls
BayRobin asks what a good service writer would: the concern, year, make, model, mileage and whether they'll wait. It treats a car that won't start or failing brakes as urgent and never diagnoses over the phone. See the AI receptionist.
The booking becomes the job
The appointment lands on the dispatch board with the vehicle, gets a confirmation and a day-before reminder, and later the inspection, estimate and invoice hang off the same record.
Flat monthly price
No per-call charges and no per-call add-ons for booking or recording: call time comes from the plan's monthly credits.
Missed callers get a text
A caller who hangs up hears from you within a minute. See missed-call text-back.
Who should choose which
Choose Smith.ai if
- You want people to handle some calls, or to take over from the AI.
- Many of your callers speak Spanish.
- You miss only a few calls a month and the free AI plan covers them.
- Bookings need to land in a CRM or calendar Smith.ai already connects to.
Choose BayRobin if
- You want every call answered by AI at a flat price.
- You want the booked appointment, reminders, estimates and invoices in one place.
- You'd like missed-call text-back and review requests included.
- Your callers speak English.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Smith.ai cost for an auto shop?
As of October 2026, its AI receptionist is free for 25 calls and $150 a month for 75 calls on Pro; human receptionists start at $300 a month for 30 calls, with $1.50 per booked appointment.
Does Smith.ai connect to Tekmetric or Shopmonkey?
Its repair-shop page names HubSpot, Zapier, Slack, Calendly, Salesforce, ServiceTitan, HighLevel and ActiveCampaign, not auto repair shop software. Ask Smith.ai what it can do for yours.
Is BayRobin an answering service?
It's an AI receptionist inside a small shop system. It answers and books calls, then handles reminders, inspections, estimates, invoices and review requests.
Can BayRobin pass a call to a person?
Urgent calls can go to whoever is on call that day, or your cell. Other callers who want a person get a message taken and you get a text to call them back.
Try it on your own shop's phone
Make a test call with a real concern and compare it with your answering service. Set up your services and hours, make a test call about a real car, and listen to how it handles it. BayRobin is free until your first 10 booked jobs, no card up front. Start free or see pricing.
Related: how BayRobin handles the AI receptionist, missed-call text-back, inspections, estimates and invoices and Ready for pickup texts, or how it works for general repair shops.
Sources
Competitor details in this post were checked against these public pages in October 2026. Products and prices change, so confirm with each vendor before you decide.
More on Shop software pricing and alternatives
BayRobin vs Tekmetric: Which Fits Your Shop? (2026)
BayRobin vs Shopmonkey: Shop Software Compared (2026)
Best AI Receptionists for Auto Repair Shops (2026)
BayRobin vs Shop-Ware: Which Should You Pick? (2026)
The Best Auto Repair Shop Software in 2026
